Back to talk

Jesus the Revolutionary

What If Christianity Was Never About the Rules

5 July 2026· Will Sopwith

Most of us carry a quiet assumption that we have to sort our lives out before we'd ever be welcome at God's table. In this talk from our Jesus the Revolutionary series, Will Sopwith walks through the moment Jesus calls Levi the tax collector and then sits down to eat with the very people everyone had written off. No bar to clear first. No list of fixes. Just an invitation offered mid-mess. Drawing on the tyranny of the school cafeteria and the story of Pandita Ramabai, Will shows a Jesus who won't stay in his lane, and asks who we'd share a table with.

Nobody's waiting for you to get it together first

There's a belief a lot of us can hold and it goes something like this, before God would want anything to do with me, I need to clean myself up. We think we should stop the thing we keep doing. Sort out the mess. Become the sort of person who belongs at God's table. So we wait. We keep our distance until we're presentable.

In this talk from our Jesus the Revolutionary series, Will Sopwith takes us to a story in the Bible that takes that whole idea apart. It's the account of a man called Levi, and it suggests the order we assume — fix yourself, then belong — might be exactly the wrong way round.

A man who wouldn't stay in his lane

The story sits in the early chapters of Mark, one of the four accounts of Jesus' life. And by this point, Will points out, Jesus is on a bit of a roll. He's turned up in a synagogue and unsettled things. He's touched a man with leprosy, which nobody did. He's told a paralysed man his wrongs were forgiven, which shocked everyone in the room. Story after story, Jesus refuses to behave the way a "respectable" religious teacher was supposed to. As Will puts it, he just will not stay in his lane.

Then comes Levi. Levi was a tax collector, which in that world meant a collaborator, someone who worked for the occupying power and skimmed off his own people for profit. To say they were despised by society would not be an understatement. And Jesus walks up to his booth and says two words: "Follow me." Levi gets up, and goes.

And if that's not enough, Levi throws a party and Jesus comes. He sits down to eat with a houseful of tax collectors and "sinners" (the label of the day for anyone deemed beyond the pale). To share a meal with someone back then wasn't casual. It said: I accept you. I'm with you. We're the same. The religious leaders are appalled. Why does he eat with these people? And Jesus gives them a line that has stuck for two thousand years:

"It's not the healthy who need a doctor, but those who are ill."

The tyranny of the school cafeteria

To help us feel what was really going on, Will reaches for something most of us know - the school canteen. There was an unspoken protocol, he says, especially in those raw teenage years when your whole social standing felt like it was on the line. Some people you simply did not sit with. And for some of us, we were those people. The sidelong glances, the sniggering behind hands, the quiet maths of who you were allowed to be seen with. Who you sat with told everyone where you ranked.

That's the pressure Jesus walks straight into and ignores. He picks the wrong table on purpose.

Pandita Ramabai and a bigger table

Will offers a second picture, one many of us won't have heard. Pandita Ramabai was born in India in 1858, the daughter of a high-caste Hindu priest who did something almost unheard of because he taught his daughter to read. She became so learned she was honoured with the name Pandita, meaning "learned one." Then life fell in on her. She was orphaned, then widowed, left to raise a young daughter alone.

She'd grown up believing God was distant, reachable only through spiritual practice tied to your caste, your education, your standing — not open to everyone. Then she encountered Jesus. And in him she found a God whose grace and acceptance were for all, regardless of caste. She almost certainly read this very story in Mark. At thirty-one she founded a centre for widows and orphans (of every caste) where they could gain skills, education and independence. She, too, refused to stay in her lane. She'd met a God with room at the table for everyone, and she built a table to match.

The two things that didn't happen

What makes the Levi story even more interesting, Will suggests, is what Jesus doesn't do.

You'd expect that once Levi signed up, he'd have to drop his dodgy old crowd. Instead he invites them all round, and Jesus happily joins the party. And you'd expect Jesus to set a bar — clean this up, prove yourself, then you can follow me. Instead, he just sits down and eats. He meets Levi exactly where he is and invites him to walk it out step by step, together.

There's no entrance exam. Jesus doesn't wait at the far side of your best efforts. He comes and sits down in the middle of the mess.

Everyone's sick, and that's the good news

In the Conversation Street chat afterwards, Matt asked, if Jesus came for the sick and not the healthy — well, who's actually healthy? "Everyone's sick," he said. The religious leaders who thought they had it sorted had missed it. So the honest question isn't am I good enough, it's am I willing to admit I'm in the same boat as everyone else?

Which knocks over the old assumption for good. Jenny added to the comments, "I definitely thought Christianity meant rules." Loads of people do — inside the church and out. But as Matt put it, you don't figure it all out and then come. You come, and Jesus helps you figure it out. Like wedding vows. You can say them in thirty seconds, then spend a lifetime living them out.

And if the worry is that faith just swaps one set of chains for another, there's a reframe worth thinking about in that you're already bound to something — approval, your salary, how work is going, the need to prove yourself. Nobody's truly free of everything. A free person simply gets to choose what binds them. Jesus put it as a yoke — the wooden frame that harnesses an animal to its work — and then said the amazing thing, "My yoke is easy and my burden is light." Still a bind. Just a kinder one, carried with help.

A table with your name on it

So here's the question Will leaves us with. Which of them are you — the shocked righteous one, the awkward companion, or the grateful guest who can't quite believe someone chose to sit with them?

You don't have to have it sorted. You don't have to clear a bar first. That was never the deal. If any of this stirred something, come and carry on the conversation with us — you'd be genuinely welcome, exactly as you are, at crowd.church.

Notes

What If Christianity Was Never About the Rules

Ever felt like you had to sort your life out before God would want anything to do with you? This week Will Sopwith looks at a story where Jesus does the exact opposite. Speaking on Mark 2:13–17 in the Jesus the Revolutionary series, with Anna Kettle and Matt Edmundson hosting, it is an honest conversation about grace, belonging, and being welcomed as you are.

Key points

  • Jesus calls Levi, a tax collector nobody respected, straight from his booth, then sits down to eat at his house with the very people polite society had written off. Sharing a meal meant friendship and acceptance, and that is what made it so shocking.
  • Right across these early chapters, Jesus refuses to stay in his lane, a run of moments that upend what everyone expected of a religious teacher.
  • Will draws two pictures of who we sit with and why. The tyranny of the school cafeteria, where your standing hung on the table you chose. And Pandita Ramabai, born in India in 1858, who met Jesus, crossed every social line of her day, and founded a home for widows and orphans of every caste.
  • The religious leaders were not bad people, Will suggests. They just had bad assumptions. They had no story for people changing. Everyone was stuck in their lane.
  • Jesus meets Levi exactly where he is. No bar to clear first. No demand to drop his friends. As Jesus puts it, it is not the healthy who need a doctor but the sick.
  • A closing challenge. Are you a shocked righteous one, an awkward companion, or a grateful sinner? And do not let your expectations of Jesus get in the way of really seeing him.

Conversation Street highlights

Where the talk ends and the real conversation begins. Here is some of where it went once the community joined in.

  • Nobody actually has it together. Jesus came for the sick, not the healthy, and as Matt put it, everyone is sick. So which camp do you put yourself in, fine or honest?
  • You do not have to fix yourself first. The idea that you must tidy up your life before coming to Jesus gets turned on its head. Levi is invited mid-mess, and Jesus never asks him to drop his old friends.
  • Faith is more like a marriage than a rulebook. Vows take thirty seconds, Matt noted, but you spend a lifetime working them out.
  • A free man gets to choose what binds him. Everyone is tied to something: approval, salary, work. Following Jesus is choosing your yoke, and his is the one that is meant to be easy and light.
  • Get to the story. Behind every hot-potato belief there is a story. Loving people well means getting past the surface to what Matt called level three, and the reminder that we are asked to love everyone, not to like everyone.

The community brought some of the most honest moments:

  • Ellis shared, "In regard to rules, I've often been caught out thinking if I do or don't do X, Y and Z then I'm in the wrong — but even though something feels that way, it doesn't mean it's true," and later pointed the room to Jesus' words on the yoke.
  • Alicia opened up about a hard season: "Because my father was so ill during my teens, I remember craving some influence over the situation, and falling into the trap of trying to follow divine law to the letter in the hopes God would show mercy. All that ended up doing was making me feel afraid of and distant from God — and then I had to work my way back to the innocent closeness I'd felt to him in my childhood." She also reflected on loving your neighbour as yourself: "one of the simplest to understand, but one of the most difficult to put into practice."
  • Jenny, back on the livestream after a while away, said, "I definitely thought that Christianity meant rules — you had to follow the rules and be a certain way before you could be a Christian."
  • Anna was honest too, about the pattern of over-performing for God, trying to prove herself faithful through hard seasons in the hope he would act.
  • Marco summed up the night simply: "Excellent topics discussed tonight."

About Crowd Church

Crowd Church is an online community for people who are not sure about church. Whether you have been part of one for years or have never stepped foot inside, you are welcome here. We are figuring this out together, asking honest questions, wrestling with real life, and making room for everyone at the table. Come and join the conversation at crowd.church.

Crowd Church — a community for those who might not see the point of church.