Jesus the Revolutionary
What Is Truth and Why Does It Set You Free?
15 November 2026· Matt Edmundson
Matt Edmundson explores Pilate's question to Jesus in John 18, "what is truth", and why Pilate asked it then walked out before the answer. Opening with his own story of a trusted company that cost his family dearly, he looks at why we've stopped trusting almost anyone, and separates three things we lump together under one word: subjective truth, relative truth and objective truth. From there he turns to Jesus' claim "I am the truth", arguing the answer was never a concept but a Person, and unpacks the promise of John 8 that the truth will set you free. Includes the Conversation Street discussion with Sharon Edmundson and Will Sopwith.
There's a strange kind of anger you feel when you realise you've been lied to. Not the ordinary irritation of a bad day, but something deeper, especially when the lie touches the people you love. Matt knows that anger well, and this week at Crowd he told us why.
Years ago he suggested to his mum that she release some equity from the house she'd fought so hard to keep. She'd paid off the mortgage as a single mum working several jobs, and the plan was to buy a second property she could let out and lean on in retirement. She didn't fully understand it, but she trusted him. So he found a company that had been recommended to him, a Christian business run by a Christian, and they bought a house in Manchester on that company's advice. What nobody mentioned was that the company was weeks away from going into administration.
So, what happens to your trust when the person you relied on turns out to be hiding something?
Why We've Stopped Trusting Anything
There was no lie told to Matt's face. But as he put it, not saying something has consequences too. He felt deceived, he lost a chunk of his mum's money, and he felt like he'd let her down. Maybe for you it wasn't money. Maybe it was a person who swore they'd change, an institution you believed in, or a headline you shared and then found out wasn't true.
Remember the photo of the Pope in a white puffer jacket? Completely AI-generated, and yet it went viral because a lot of us thought it was real. It was one of the first times many people realised we can't fully trust our own eyes anymore. And when you see enough counterfeits, you stop trusting the real thing.
Every year the research company Ipsos asks the British public who they actually trust to tell the truth. Nurses sit right at the top, trusted by 94% of us. A long way down, around 70% of us think journalists mislead people on purpose. And at the very bottom, as ever, politicians land somewhere near 11%. We have a problem with trust, and underneath it we have a problem with truth. Who is actually telling us the truth?
The Man Who Asked the Biggest Question and Walked Out
It's the night before Jesus is killed. He's been arrested and dragged in front of the Roman governor, Pontius Pilate. The conversation turns, strangely, to kingship and then to truth.
"So you are a king?" Pilate asked. Jesus responded, "You say I am a king. Actually, I was born and came into the world to testify to the truth. All who love the truth recognise that what I say is true." "What is truth?" Pilate asked.
And then something remarkable happens. Pilate doesn't wait. The very next line tells us he turned, walked back outside to the crowd, and told them he found no case against this man.
He asked the biggest question a human being can ask, to the one Person in history actually able to answer it, and he didn't stay in the room long enough to hear a single word. He asked the question. He just wouldn't stay for the answer.
Your Truth, My Truth, and the Three Things We've Jammed Together
Pilate isn't the only one who does that. Wrestling with truth is hard, because it means accepting that something can be true whether we like it or not.
"Your truth, my truth" is the mantra of the age. You respect mine, I'll respect yours, and nobody gets to tell anyone otherwise. And underneath it is something genuinely good, because you shouldn't be bullied into someone else's version of you. The trouble is we're using one word, truth, to mean three different things, and we've stacked them on top of each other.
The first is subjective truth. This is the genuine "my truth" space, and it's where the phrase actually works. Matt's example? Liverpool Football Club is the best club in the world. It just is. It's true for him, it's not true for everyone, and nobody needs to come and correct it. That's fine.
The second is relative truth. The example Matt used was speed. As he said, he was sitting still, moving at zero miles an hour relative to the walls around him. True enough. But you and I are also hurtling around the sun at around 67,000 miles an hour. So is he still or is he moving? Both, at the same time. It depends on your point of reference. The Bible says of itself that God's word is truth, and that's our ultimate reference point. What you feel and what you're going through is real and true, the way Matt's stillness is true, and it's held in tension next to a bigger truth.
The third is objective truth. This one is true for everybody, full stop, like gravity. You can't say gravity isn't your truth, because step off a building and it very much is. It can't be true for you and false for me. And the moment someone wrongs us, we're furious at the injustice, and injustice only makes sense if there's a truth that applies to everyone. We need objective truth to even function as people. It's a good thing. Problems creep in when we take something objective and treat it like it's subjective.
What Jesus Meant When He Said I Am the Truth
Jesus told him, "I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one can come to the Father except through me." (John 14:6)
When Jesus says "I am the truth", that isn't a "best football club in the world" kind of statement. It's a gravity kind of statement. It's either true for everybody or it's true for nobody. It can't just be a private, personal truth.
And this is where it gets interesting. Pilate asked "what is truth", assuming the answer was a what. But the answer isn't a concept at all. Jesus didn't say "I know the truth". He said "I am the truth". The Greek word John uses is aletheia, which carries the sense of what is real, what's actually the case. Jesus isn't claiming to have the best argument about God. He's claiming the truth of God is embodied in Him. As He put it, whoever has seen Him has seen the Father.
If truth is ultimately a Person and not merely an idea, then the question stops being "what do I think about this?" and becomes "what am I going to do with Him?" And that question costs you something. Which is maybe why Pilate did what we all do when the answer is bigger than we can handle. He asked the question, then got out of the room before it could change him.
The Truth Will Set You Free
There's a famous promise Jesus makes about all this.
Jesus said to the people who believed in him, "You are truly my disciples if you remain faithful to my teachings. And you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free." (John 8:31-32)
Notice what it doesn't say. Not the truth will inform you. The truth will set you free.
A truth you invent for yourself can never really free you, because you can change it the second life gets uncomfortable. But a truth that exists outside you, one you didn't construct and didn't get to vote on, is the kind of truth that can actually hold you up. Free from your past, free from your shame, your fear, your old identity, everything that wants to steal and kill and destroy you. As Jesus said in John 10:10, "The thief's purpose is to steal and kill and destroy. My purpose is to give them a rich and satisfying life."
It Doesn't Always Tie Up in a Neat Bow
So what about the property company, the one whose silence cost Matt's family so much? It took the best part of fifteen years, but by God's grace every penny was paid back. His mum's house, the one she fought so hard for, is hers again. Free and clear, the way it always should have been.
He's honest that it doesn't tie up in a neat bow, though. He still carries the fact that she trusted him and it went wrong. But what he keeps coming back to is that it went wrong because of a lack of truth.
Pilate had Jesus in the room. He asked the right question. He was three feet from the answer to the only question that really matters, and he walked out before he heard it.
Stay in the Room
The answer to "what is truth" was never a concept you win or lose an argument about. The answer has always been a Person, and He's still in the room. He isn't asking you to have it all figured out tonight. He's asking you to stay long enough to listen.
If something stirred in you reading this, and sometimes the heart recognises truth before the mind has caught up, the simplest thing you can do isn't to sort it all out. It's just not to walk away. You could pray something honest, like this.
Jesus, if You really are the truth, then I want to stay in the room. Help me not to walk out.
Where the Conversation Went Next
After the talk, Matt, Sharon and Will picked up one question in Conversation Street. When was the last time you asked a big question about God, about life, about yourself, and then walked out before you had the chance to hear the answer?
Will reflected that if Pilate was distracted, how much more are we? The big questions tend to arrive in the middle of the night, and two minutes later something else has grabbed our attention and the question is gone. Sharon recognised the pattern in herself. She and Matt have had a frustrating stretch trying to find a house since moving out in August, and over lunch that day a friend named Nic asked her, "what do you think God is saying in this?" She realised she'd been half-listening all along, asking the question but never properly taking stock of the answer. Matt's own version comes when he's so sure of his theology that he stops asking whether it's true, and Alicia noted in the comments that she's asked "why me?" and then backed away from praying for the answer.
Sharon also asked where people had experienced the freedom Jesus promises. For Will it was worth. He'd carried the world's scoreboard of achievement and money and the constant doubt of whether he measured up, and the freeing truth was that God's love for him wouldn't change even if he achieved nothing at all. For Matt it came down to identity, holding his own opinion of himself up against what God says, like a mirror, and finding the two don't always match. Dionne added that we tend to be impatient waiting for truth, a by-product of a culture that doesn't value waiting, which is exactly why so much of the Christian life looks less like reading an answer off a page and more like wrestling it out.
Notes
What Is Truth and Why Does It Set You Free?
Ever asked a huge question about God or your life, then walked off before the answer could reach you?
About this episode
In this talk Matt Edmundson digs into the biggest question a person can ask, what is truth, and the odd kind of freedom that comes with the answer. He starts somewhere painful, a trusted company that said nothing while his mum's money slipped away, and uses it to get at why trust feels so fragile right now. From AI fakes to politicians to pastors in the headlines, when we see enough counterfeits we stop trusting the real thing. Then he heads to a night in John's gospel where Pilate asks Jesus what is truth and walks out before the answer lands. Along the way Matt untangles three different things we all mean by that one word truth, why "I am the truth" is a very different kind of claim, and why a truth you invent for yourself can never actually set you free. It ends gently, with an invitation to stay in the room long enough to listen.
Timestamps
- 00:00 Welcome and notices
- 07:22 A lie that cost his family
- 10:41 When counterfeits make us stop trusting
- 12:24 Pilate asks the biggest question
- 16:33 Three kinds of truth
- 20:21 Truth is a person, not a what
- 24:02 The truth that sets you free
- 25:30 Still in the room, an invitation
- 27:30 Conversation Street
Key points and takeaways
- There is a particular anger that shows up when you realise you have been lied to. Sometimes nobody said anything false to your face, but staying silent can deceive just as much, and it can cost the people you love.
- We are surrounded by fakes now, AI images, broken promises, people and institutions that let us down. The trouble is that when you see enough counterfeits, you slowly stop trusting the real thing too.
- We use one word, truth, to mean three different things. Subjective truth is the genuinely personal stuff (your football team is the best, and that is fine). Relative truth depends on where you are standing (you are sitting still and hurtling round the sun at 67,000 miles an hour, both at once). Objective truth is simply true for everyone, like gravity, whether you like it or not.
- The mistake is taking something objective and treating it like it is only subjective. When Jesus says "I am the truth", that is an objective claim, not a my-truth preference. It is either true for everybody or true for nobody.
- Pilate assumed truth was a what. The surprise is that truth turned out to be a Who. Once truth is a person, the question stops being "what do I think about this?" and becomes "what am I going to do with Him?", and that question costs something.
- A truth you invent for yourself can never set you free, because you can change it the second life gets uncomfortable. A truth that exists outside you, that you did not construct and did not get to vote on, is the kind that can actually hold you.
- Pilate asked exactly the right question and then walked out before he heard a single word of the answer. The invitation is simply not to do the same. You do not need it all figured out tonight, you just need to stay in the room and listen.
Key references
- John 18, Pilate and Jesus, "What is truth?"
- John 14:6, "I am the way, the truth and the life"
- John 8:31-32, "you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free"
- John 10:10, the thief comes to steal, kill and destroy
- Genesis 32, Jacob wrestling through the night
- James 1:6, tossed to and fro by every wave and wind
- The Ipsos trust survey (nurses trusted by 94%, politicians by around 11%)
- The viral AI image of the Pope in a puffer jacket
Quotes from the talk
He asked the biggest question a human being can ask, to the one person in history actually able to answer it, and he didn't stay in the room long enough to hear a single word.
A truth that you invent for yourself can never actually set you free, because you can change it in a second.
The answer to the question, what is truth, was never a concept or an argument you win or lose. The answer has always been a person, and He's still in the room.
Conversation Street
Where the talk ends and the real conversation begins. Matt left the community with one question, "when was the last time you asked a big question about God, about life, about yourself, and then walked out of the room before you had a chance to hear?"
Will owned up to the obvious trap first. If Pilate was distracted, how much more are we. The big questions often arrive in the middle of the night, and we roll over and go back to sleep, or they surface first thing and then the day gets busy and swallows them. What stays with him is how patient God is, answering in several different forms until the message finally gets through.
Sharon admitted she tends to half listen, asking the question but then getting distracted before she really pays attention. Over lunch that day with Nic, one of the founding couples of their church, Nic asked her straight, "what do you think God is saying in this?" (she and Matt have been outbid again and again house hunting since moving out in August), and she realised she had never properly stopped to take stock of the answer.
Matt named his own version of Pilate, the moments he gets too dogmatic. "I don't ever need to question what is true, because I know what is true." Looking back, the theology he held 20 years ago is not the theology he holds now, and he has learned not to assume he already has the answer but to wrestle it out instead.
From the chat, Alicia shared that she has sometimes asked "why me?", then backed away from considering or praying for the answer. Kath raised a sharp point about whether Pilate's question was even sincere or more of a rhetorical, cynical dismissal, which Will picked up, wondering if Pilate was so steeped in the spin of the Roman Empire that he had stopped believing truth existed at all. Will added that the same worn out cynicism can stop us hearing God, if we bring the suspicion we reserve for politicians and headlines to Him as well.
Sharon offered a hopeful counterweight. Counterfeits only work because there is a real thing for them to copy, so the existence of so many fakes points to something genuine underneath. When she asked where people had experienced Jesus setting them free, Will pointed to worth, the exhausting pressure to earn his place, and the freedom of knowing God's love for him would not change even if he achieved nothing. Matt landed on identity too, holding what he believes about himself up against the mirror of God's word, and being set free from shame.
Dionne summed up a thread that ran through the whole conversation, "I think we humans can be quite impatient when waiting for truth to be realised, a byproduct of a society that doesn't value waiting or patience." Matt agreed, pointing back to Jacob wrestling through the night. Truth is rarely something you jot on a Post-it, more often it is something you have to search out and wrestle for.
Links
- Explore Crowd Church at crowd.church
- Alpha Course, a relaxed space to ask honest questions about faith, starts online in January, Wednesday the 13th at 7:30pm UK time. Sign up on the website.
- Live Lounge, a Zoom room to carry on the conversation after the livestream, at go.crowd.church/livelounge
- Midweek groups meet on Wednesdays at 7:30pm UK time. Details on the website.
- In-person meetups, the Chester Christmas market and London on the 5th of December. Sign up on the website.
About Crowd Church
Crowd Church is a digital-first church, based in Liverpool and reaching online across the UK and around the world. It is church for people who are not sure about church, a space where anyone exploring faith and anyone who has followed Jesus for years can work things out together, honestly and without pretence. Every Sunday there is a talk, a Conversation Street Q&A, and a community you can actually talk to, whether you have been part of church for years or have never stepped foot in one.
Join the conversation at crowd.church.
For more info, please visit https://crowd.church/talks/what-is-truth-and-why-does-it-set-you-free.
Crowd Church, a community for those who might not see the point of church.