Jesus the Revolutionary

What Is Truth and Why Does It Set You Free?

15 November 2026 · Matt Edmundson

Matt Edmundson explores Pilate's question to Jesus in John 18, "what is truth", and why Pilate asked it then walked out before the answer. Opening with his own story of a trusted company that cost his family dearly, he looks at why we've stopped trusting almost anyone, and separates three things we lump together under one word: subjective truth, relative truth and objective truth. From there he turns to Jesus' claim "I am the truth", arguing the answer was never a concept but a Person, and unpacks the promise of John 8 that the truth will set you free. Includes the Conversation Street discussion with Sharon Edmundson and Will Sopwith.

01Talk notes

There's a strange kind of anger you feel when you realise you've been lied to. Not the ordinary irritation of a bad day, but something deeper, especially when the lie touches the people you love. Matt knows that anger well, and this week at Crowd he told us why.

Years ago he suggested to his mum that she release some equity from the house she'd fought so hard to keep. She'd paid off the mortgage as a single mum working several jobs, and the plan was to buy a second property she could let out and lean on in retirement. She didn't fully understand it, but she trusted him. So he found a company that had been recommended to him, a Christian business run by a Christian, and they bought a house in Manchester on that company's advice. What nobody mentioned was that the company was weeks away from going into administration.

So, what happens to your trust when the person you relied on turns out to be hiding something?

02Why We've Stopped Trusting Anything

There was no lie told to Matt's face. But as he put it, not saying something has consequences too. He felt deceived, he lost a chunk of his mum's money, and he felt like he'd let her down. Maybe for you it wasn't money. Maybe it was a person who swore they'd change, an institution you believed in, or a headline you shared and then found out wasn't true.

Remember the photo of the Pope in a white puffer jacket? Completely AI-generated, and yet it went viral because a lot of us thought it was real. It was one of the first times many people realised we can't fully trust our own eyes anymore. And when you see enough counterfeits, you stop trusting the real thing.

Every year the research company Ipsos asks the British public who they actually trust to tell the truth. Nurses sit right at the top, trusted by 94% of us. A long way down, around 70% of us think journalists mislead people on purpose. And at the very bottom, as ever, politicians land somewhere near 11%. We have a problem with trust, and underneath it we have a problem with truth. Who is actually telling us the truth?

03The Man Who Asked the Biggest Question and Walked Out

It's the night before Jesus is killed. He's been arrested and dragged in front of the Roman governor, Pontius Pilate. The conversation turns, strangely, to kingship and then to truth.

"So you are a king?" Pilate asked. Jesus responded, "You say I am a king. Actually, I was born and came into the world to testify to the truth. All who love the truth recognise that what I say is true." "What is truth?" Pilate asked.

And then something remarkable happens. Pilate doesn't wait. The very next line tells us he turned, walked back outside to the crowd, and told them he found no case against this man.

He asked the biggest question a human being can ask, to the one Person in history actually able to answer it, and he didn't stay in the room long enough to hear a single word. He asked the question. He just wouldn't stay for the answer.

04Your Truth, My Truth, and the Three Things We've Jammed Together

Pilate isn't the only one who does that. Wrestling with truth is hard, because it means accepting that something can be true whether we like it or not.

"Your truth, my truth" is the mantra of the age. You respect mine, I'll respect yours, and nobody gets to tell anyone otherwise. And underneath it is something genuinely good, because you shouldn't be bullied into someone else's version of you. The trouble is we're using one word, truth, to mean three different things, and we've stacked them on top of each other.

The first is subjective truth. This is the genuine "my truth" space, and it's where the phrase actually works. Matt's example? Liverpool Football Club is the best club in the world. It just is. It's true for him, it's not true for everyone, and nobody needs to come and correct it. That's fine.

The second is relative truth. The example Matt used was speed. As he said, he was sitting still, moving at zero miles an hour relative to the walls around him. True enough. But you and I are also hurtling around the sun at around 67,000 miles an hour. So is he still or is he moving? Both, at the same time. It depends on your point of reference. The Bible says of itself that God's word is truth, and that's our ultimate reference point. What you feel and what you're going through is real and true, the way Matt's stillness is true, and it's held in tension next to a bigger truth.

The third is objective truth. This one is true for everybody, full stop, like gravity. You can't say gravity isn't your truth, because step off a building and it very much is. It can't be true for you and false for me. And the moment someone wrongs us, we're furious at the injustice, and injustice only makes sense if there's a truth that applies to everyone. We need objective truth to even function as people. It's a good thing. Problems creep in when we take something objective and treat it like it's subjective.

05What Jesus Meant When He Said I Am the Truth

Jesus told him, "I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one can come to the Father except through me." (John 14:6)

When Jesus says "I am the truth", that isn't a "best football club in the world" kind of statement. It's a gravity kind of statement. It's either true for everybody or it's true for nobody. It can't just be a private, personal truth.

And this is where it gets interesting. Pilate asked "what is truth", assuming the answer was a what. But the answer isn't a concept at all. Jesus didn't say "I know the truth". He said "I am the truth". The Greek word John uses is aletheia, which carries the sense of what is real, what's actually the case. Jesus isn't claiming to have the best argument about God. He's claiming the truth of God is embodied in Him. As He put it, whoever has seen Him has seen the Father.

If truth is ultimately a Person and not merely an idea, then the question stops being "what do I think about this?" and becomes "what am I going to do with Him?" And that question costs you something. Which is maybe why Pilate did what we all do when the answer is bigger than we can handle. He asked the question, then got out of the room before it could change him.

06The Truth Will Set You Free

There's a famous promise Jesus makes about all this.

Jesus said to the people who believed in him, "You are truly my disciples if you remain faithful to my teachings. And you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free." (John 8:31-32)

Notice what it doesn't say. Not the truth will inform you. The truth will set you free.

A truth you invent for yourself can never really free you, because you can change it the second life gets uncomfortable. But a truth that exists outside you, one you didn't construct and didn't get to vote on, is the kind of truth that can actually hold you up. Free from your past, free from your shame, your fear, your old identity, everything that wants to steal and kill and destroy you. As Jesus said in John 10:10, "The thief's purpose is to steal and kill and destroy. My purpose is to give them a rich and satisfying life."

07It Doesn't Always Tie Up in a Neat Bow

So what about the property company, the one whose silence cost Matt's family so much? It took the best part of fifteen years, but by God's grace every penny was paid back. His mum's house, the one she fought so hard for, is hers again. Free and clear, the way it always should have been.

He's honest that it doesn't tie up in a neat bow, though. He still carries the fact that she trusted him and it went wrong. But what he keeps coming back to is that it went wrong because of a lack of truth.

Pilate had Jesus in the room. He asked the right question. He was three feet from the answer to the only question that really matters, and he walked out before he heard it.

08Stay in the Room

The answer to "what is truth" was never a concept you win or lose an argument about. The answer has always been a Person, and He's still in the room. He isn't asking you to have it all figured out tonight. He's asking you to stay long enough to listen.

If something stirred in you reading this, and sometimes the heart recognises truth before the mind has caught up, the simplest thing you can do isn't to sort it all out. It's just not to walk away. You could pray something honest, like this.

Jesus, if You really are the truth, then I want to stay in the room. Help me not to walk out.

09Where the Conversation Went Next

After the talk, Matt, Sharon and Will picked up one question in Conversation Street. When was the last time you asked a big question about God, about life, about yourself, and then walked out before you had the chance to hear the answer?

Will reflected that if Pilate was distracted, how much more are we? The big questions tend to arrive in the middle of the night, and two minutes later something else has grabbed our attention and the question is gone. Sharon recognised the pattern in herself. She and Matt have had a frustrating stretch trying to find a house since moving out in August, and over lunch that day a friend named Nic asked her, "what do you think God is saying in this?" She realised she'd been half-listening all along, asking the question but never properly taking stock of the answer. Matt's own version comes when he's so sure of his theology that he stops asking whether it's true, and Alicia noted in the comments that she's asked "why me?" and then backed away from praying for the answer.

Sharon also asked where people had experienced the freedom Jesus promises. For Will it was worth. He'd carried the world's scoreboard of achievement and money and the constant doubt of whether he measured up, and the freeing truth was that God's love for him wouldn't change even if he achieved nothing at all. For Matt it came down to identity, holding his own opinion of himself up against what God says, like a mirror, and finding the two don't always match. Dionne added that we tend to be impatient waiting for truth, a by-product of a culture that doesn't value waiting, which is exactly why so much of the Christian life looks less like reading an answer off a page and more like wrestling it out.

View Full Transcript

Sharon: Hello and welcome to Crowd Church. I'm Sharon and I'm hosting tonight along with the fabulous Will.

Will: Good evening, nice to see you. How's everyone doing? We get people from all over the world at Crowd, so maybe, uh, as a, as a start off, you could, uh, you could put in the chat where you're, where, where you're dialling in from.

Sharon: Um, yeah, so if you basically— if you're, um, part of the community, fabulous to be with you. It's always great to get to know you more. Uh, if you're new, we are an online church, as I've said. Um, we are filming from Liverpool, but actually our members are all around the UK and all around the world. So it's great to have you along with us. Um, Will, would you like to explain about Live Lounge? We've got a lot of—

Will: Yes.

Sharon: A lot of information for you tonight.

Will: So, so Crowd Church is a church, but it's online. And, uh, we're always discussing, asking God, uh, thinking through how we can build more of a community, um, given that we're quite disparately spread around the internet. And so one of the things is Live Lounge, uh, which has just started this term. And this is a, a Zoom room effectively, uh, where you can gather with others. Um, and you see everything on the live lounge. You can, uh, you can hear the talk, you can hear the conversation. And then afterwards, at about quarter to 8, uh, the conversation moves into that Zoom room. Um, so if you're interested in connecting with others rather than just being on the chat on YouTube, um, then please do, uh, dive into the live lounge. Uh, the link is—

Sharon: On the screen, hopefully.

Will: On the screen.

Sharon: It's very small from here, so I'm not— can't quite read it myself.

Will: I mean, the Live Lounge is a little bit, a little bit more personal, um, and yeah, but you, you can, you can still go on there and honestly without, without a camera. I hope Dan, who's hosting Live Lounge, won't, uh, won't hate me too much for saying that. Um, but otherwise, please do, um, participate in the chat, um, and we try to answer as many questions as we can. after the talk, so please do be typing away, uh, in the chat, uh, as we go through.

Sharon: The next thing I'd like to talk to you about is Alpha. Um, I don't know if you've heard about Alpha. It's a course which is for people who are searching. Maybe you've got questions about faith, about Christianity, and you just like a safe place where you can just come be yourself, ask your questions, and not be preached at, not be shouted down for your opinions. And we've got another Alpha course starting online in January. It will be from Wednesday the 13th at 7:30 UK time. You can sign up for that on the website. So that will be fabulous if you could join us for that. Or it's even great, isn't it, if you're already a Christian but you've— again, you've got questions and you just want to go over some of the foundational stuff of the faith. Yeah. It's great for that as well.

Will: Yeah,

Sharon: um, you don't have to have your camera on for that. You don't need to speak initially if you— yeah, it can be a bit daunting, can't it?

Will: It can, but, but through— I mean, certainly my experience of doing an alpha last year, and, and, uh, and we have some people still part of Crowd from that, um, it really becomes actually quite a good community as you meet week after week and you're hearing each other's stories a little bit and you're asking questions and you're hearing each other's point of view. Um, bit by bit the cameras come on and, uh, and actually it's a really lovely sense of, of community. Um, so yeah, really, really recommend Alpha if you've got questions about the Christian faith.

Sharon: Yeah.

Will: And about Jesus, do come along.

Sharon: Cool. So we've also, um, if you want a little bit more connection, we're having a couple of meetups in the UK. So we've got one on Saturday in Chester at the Christmas market at 1 o'clock if you'd like to come and actually meet real people in real life. Join us for that. If you go to the website, you can sign up for that. Just put your email in and we'll give you a bit more information about that. And we've got one in London because obviously we're a little bit spread out. Unfortunately, we can't do every country in the world, but the one in— Next year. Maybe.

Matt: New York, I think.

Will: New York should definitely be on that list.

Sharon: Yeah.

Matt: I was thinking more Tahiti.

Sharon: Oh, this other voice you can hear, I've not actually introduced him yet. This is Matt. Hello everyone. Sorry, forgot about that bit.

Matt: She forgot about her husband. That's what she forgot about.

Sharon: I did think that. I will then introduce you later anyway. Yeah, this is Matt, my lovely husband. If you hear me call him babe or something else, that's why.

Matt: Just, yeah, forgive, forgive the little idiosyncrasies between my wife and I.

Sharon: Yeah, we forget sometimes and Yeah, so he will be speaking in a bit, but I think we will, we will come back to you and include you a little bit more.

Matt: Phew.

Sharon: Yeah, so as I was saying, we've also got a London meetup, which is the 5th of December, the Christmas markets there. Again, you can sign up for that on the website and you'll be given more information. So just so that you know, if you are new tonight, how this works is now that we've got all those notices out of the way, Matt is going to come with a talk which we'll introduce a little bit. And then after that, we're going to, as a 3 here and hopefully with all of you, join in a conversation together with our questions, our comments, just a bit of a discussion just to go a little bit deeper into that. Yeah. And then we'll have that discussion for a few minutes and then we'll actually stop the livestream and we're going to jump into Zoom room, the live lounge, and you can join us there as well if you prefer. Yeah, so, Will.

Will: Expertly done, Sharon. So it is actually the Edmo Show this evening. Matt and Sharon Edmo. And we've been doing a series for, I mean, it feels like forever now, actually. Jesus the Revolutionary. And just the number of weeks we've had. I was just reflecting on this, that, um, you know, if you've, if you've done any even cursory research into the reality, the historical reality of Jesus, uh, being real and, uh, the authenticity of written-down, uh, stories about him, um, actually he's very hard to ignore. And we've covered a lot of those things in this Jesus the Revolutionary series. Some of those have been completely groundbreaking, culturally challenging things that he said and did. Um, some of them have been just outrageous. And tonight possibly is more on the outrageous end. Um, we are talking about that, uh, pithy topic,

Matt: truth. Pithy topic.

Will: Pithy. I mean, I'm sure it will be pithy. Um, because truth is, well, I won't steal Matt's thunder, but I mean, what, yeah, what a little thing to deal with on a Sunday evening.

Matt: Yeah.

Will: Um, so with no further ado, I will introduce, uh, Matthew Edmundson. And, uh, over to you, Matt, and look forward to, uh, chatting later in Conversation Street.

Matt: Yeah, thanks, Will. Loving this, talking about truth. Let me say hello to everybody in the— I can see in the live lounge, uh, I can see Kath, I can see Ros and Rich, I can see Darcy and Talita. You've— you, you're connected now, uh, which is awesome, which is great. Sorry if you You have no idea what I'm talking about. The burgers. I can see Live Lounge and who's in there. So if you do want to go join Live Lounge, it'd be great. I can see you in there, and a warm welcome to everyone in the comments. Yes, we are talking about truth. Now let's talk about anger for a minute. There's a strange type of anger, isn't there? You feel when you realize that you've been lied to. Maybe it's just me. We all know the feeling, right? One particular occasion. I was incredibly angry because this lie didn't just impact me, but also my family, and it also impacted my mum. So to understand why I suppose I was angry about this, you have to understand my mum. And if you can do that, please let me know how you figured her out. Uh, my, my parents divorced, uh, early in the 1980s when I was a young lad, and she had to work Multiple jobs just to keep the same roof over our heads. She fought so fiercely to keep the house we grew up in, and you know what? She did it too. She paid off the mortgage as a single mum working multiple jobs, and to this day, she is one of the people I admire most on the planet. She is an absolute legend. And then one day after she'd paid it off, we were talking about her her pension and how there wasn't much of it. So I introduced the idea of her releasing equity from the house to buy a property. That she could let out. Now, Mum didn't really get it, but she trusted me and handed over a chunk of her cash. And obviously, naturally, I wanted to do a good job for her. So I connected with a company that was recommended to me. It was a Christian company run by a Christian, and they sourced and managed property for you. And it seemed like a win-win, really. And so we ended up buying a house in Manchester based on that company's advice. But what they never told me was that the company was weeks away from going into administration. Now, sure, there was no direct lie to my face, but not saying stuff also has implications, doesn't it? Now, I get that businesses go under. I get that that happens. But I was angry because I had felt deceived. And I'd I was angry because I'd lost a chunk of my mum's money. As a result, I felt like I'd let her down, and I hated that. Hence the reason I felt angry. And I'm pretty sure you know a similar sort of feeling. Maybe for you it's not money. Maybe it was a person who swore they'd change, or an institution you believed in. Maybe a, you know, in the press at the moment is the celebrity, isn't it? Or a pastor. Perhaps a headline you shared that you found out Wasn't true, which is a deception I think that's become so easy these days, especially with social media and AI. I don't know if you remember this image. Now, this is a photo of the Pope in a puffer jacket. Okay. Now, um, it went around a few years ago. It was completely AI generated, but at the time, a lot of us thought it was real, and it did go viral. And this was one of the first times I think the majority of people properly realized that we can't quite trust our own eyes anymore, especially with AI doing its thing. And when you see enough counterfeits, you stop trusting the real thing, don't you? And ultimately, you get to a place where you're not sure what is even true anymore. Every year, a company called Ipsos sampled the opinion of the British public. Who do you actually trust to tell you the truth is a question right now. Right at the top of this, as you would expect, is nurses. 94% of us trust the nurses. Quite a, quite a ways behind, let's say, 70% of us think that journalists mislead people on purpose, right? So journalists bad. We can't trust the media. We can't trust journalists. And of course, right at the bottom of that list is, since pretty much it started really, politicians, about 11%, uh, which won't come as a surprise, will it really? Not in the current climate. Bottom line is this is not good, is it? Uh, who do you trust? And we have a problem with trust because we have a problem with truth? Who is telling us the truth? And as you would expect, the Bible has something to say about truth. And to help us understand what, we're going to look at a chap called Pilate. Now let me set the scene here. It's the night before Jesus will be killed. He's been arrested and dragged in front of the Roman governor, our man Pontius Pilate. So let me put the scriptures on the screen. Uh, so it says, uh, let me put my glasses on so I can read it properly. There we go. Yes. Pilate went back into his headquarters and called for Jesus to be brought to him. Are you the King of Jews? he asked. And Jesus replied, is this your own question, or did others tell you about me? Um, am I a Jew? Pilate retorted. Your own people and their leading priests brought you to me for trial. Why? What have you done? Jesus answered, my kingdom is not an earthly kingdom. If it were, my followers would fight to keep me from being handed over to the Jewish leaders. But my— oh, next. Great. Yep, there we go. But my kingdom is not of this world. Pilate, uh, Pilate said, so you're a king? And then Jesus responded, you say I am a king. Actually, I was born and came into the world to testify to the truth. All who love the truth recognize that what I say is true. Okay, so here we have this sort of fascinating conversation between Pilate and Jesus about kings and kingdoms, and Jesus answers his question about being a king by talking about truth. And so Pilate follows this up, follows this up with a simple but absolutely profound question. He says, what is truth? What is truth? Pilate asked. And then he goes on to say, and then what happens is he went out again to the people and told them he is not guilty of any crime. So Pilate asked the question But he doesn't seem to wait for the answer. What is truth? And then he just sort of walks off. He turns and walks back outside to talk to the people. He asked the biggest question a human being can ask to the one person in history actually able to answer that question, and he didn't stay in the room long enough to hear a single word in the answer. And he asked the question, right? He just wouldn't stay for the answer. And that's the point here. But Pilate, I don't think, is the only man in history to do that. Wrestling with this concept of truth isn't easy because it means accepting that someone can, or something can, be true whether we like it or not. And we have to ask whether we have good reasons for what we believe. We— this is why we have to wrestle with it. So if we take the mantra, this mantra, your truth, my truth, which is sort of Well, it's the mantra of the age, isn't it, really? I— this is your truth, and I should respect it. This is my truth, you should respect that, and nobody gets to tell me otherwise. And so much of it comes out of the current therapy and wellness culture. And underneath this idea is something that is genuinely good, because you shouldn't be bullied into someone else's version of you, right? It's a defense against people that use truth, or so-called truth maybe, as a weapon. And the good news is you don't have to argue the point now because you have your truth. And it kind of sounds like we're creating a sense of peace. It almost sounds kind. It's my truth. You don't have to agree with it. It's just my truth. But if we slow right down, we see that we are using one word truth, I think, to mean 3 different things, and we sort of all jam them together. So what do I mean by that? Well, let's look at this idea of subjective truth. Okay, the first kind, subjective truth. This is actually the genuine my truth, your truth ideology. It's where it makes sense. For example, I believe fundamentally As I will, I know you do. Liverpool Football Club is the best club in the world, right? It just is.

Will: It just is.

Matt: It just is. There's no argument. We don't have to talk about this right now. Some of you may just have switched off, and that's okay, because for me, that is a true statement. It's not true for everybody. It is subjective. It's mine. And here's the thing, I'm fine with that being my truth. Nobody needs to come and correct it. Right? So that's subjective truth, that your truth, my truth idea. But I think we have to go a little level deeper than that. So let's talk about something called relative truth. What do I mean by that? Well, let's look at the topic of speed, right? A strange topic to talk about, I appreciate. It would be fair to say that right now, Currently, my speed is 0 miles an hour. I am sitting still. Okay? I am as still, well, still as I can be really. Uh, but that is a truth relative to the walls, to this screen behind me, to the camera. Okay? But here's the thing. You and I, assuming you're on planet Earth, which I assume you are, uh, we're hurtling around the sun at 67,000 miles an hour. So actually, relative to the sun, I am moving at insane speeds. I'm almost moving at warp speed, if you like. But I don't feel that. I don't see that. So which is it? Am I sitting still or am I doing 67,000 miles an hour right now? And the answer, of course, is both at the same time. It depends on your relative point of reference. Okay, and every time I change that reference point, I see maybe a higher or truer answer. For example, the galaxy moves at 1.3 million miles an hour, but let's not get into that, right? And what I find fascinating here is when we think about the Bible, the Bible says about itself that is, it is in fact truth, that God's word is truth. And I would say that's our ultimate reference point. You know, what I feel what I'm going through, my pain, my experience. That's all very real, and that's true the way my speed relative to the walls is also true. But it's held in tension next to this idea of a bigger truth, God's truth. And I think that tension is real and dynamic, and it's what we learn to hold in our Christian walk, this tension. And the third type of truth Is called objective truth. Okay? And this is true for everybody, full stop. Like gravity. Gravity is true for you and it is true for me, whether we like it or whether we don't. You can't say that gravity is not my truth because it obviously is. If you jump off a building, it is your truth, right? Uh, it can't be— gravity can't be true for you and not true for me. It has to be true for both of us. And this is where I think the sort of my truth idea slips a little bit. Not because subjective truth isn't real— it is— but because we take something that's objective and we treat it like it's subjective. So if we go back to the verse Sharon looked at 2 weeks ago, let's close that loop. Um, it says in John 14:6 that, um, Jesus said, I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one can come uh, to the Father except through me. So when Jesus says, I am the truth, this is not a relative statement. It's not a Liverpool is the best football club in the world kind of statement. It's an objective statement, like we are subject to gravity kind of statement. It is either true for everybody or it's true for nobody. It can't just be my truth. Okay, it's an objective truth statement. And objective truth, if you're following me here, is not a bad thing, right? Because even people that want to live in this sort of relative world where there is no truth, it's fine up until the point someone lies to us or someone wrongs us in some way, and then we're furious because we're outraged at the injustice. But for injustice to be a thing, there has to be an objective truth, right? If I steal all your money, why should I be punished if my truth tells me that's okay? Who are you to tell me different? So we need objective truth to function as people. It's a good thing. In fact, if we say there is no truth that applies to everyone, we have to ask, does that statement apply to everyone? It becomes a self-refuting statement. All very heavy stuff. Hopefully you're with me so far. There's a lot to this, but it goes deeper, and I get really excited about it. And to understand why, let's head back to the room where Pilate asks Jesus the question but doesn't appear to wait for the answer, which is, what is truth? Okay, what is truth? It is a profound question in so many ways, and it's one that we all wrestle with. And the question though assumes that truth is a what, which is where I wonder if Pilate goes wrong, because the answer I don't think is a what at all. What is truth? Jesus didn't say here, I know the truth. He said, I am the truth. And the Greek word which John uses is aletheia. I think that's how you pronounce it. If it's bad, please don't, don't shout me down. But in essence, it means truth, like what is real, what is actually the case, rather than what is false or merely appears to be true. So Jesus isn't simply claiming to have the best argument about God. He's claiming that the truth of God is actually embodied in himself. In fact, he says this: whoever has seen me, right, has seen the Father. He embodies the truth. If truth is ultimately a person and not merely a concept, then the question stops being, what do I think about this? And becomes, well, actually, what am I going to do with him? And I think that's a much bigger question because that question is going to cost you something. So Pilate did what we all do when the answer is bigger than what we can handle. He asked the question, and then he got out of the room before it could actually change him. Now, there's some really well-known verses about truth in the Bible which I want to dig into. Jesus said to the people who believed in him, you are truly my disciples if you remain in my teaching, or if you remain faithful to my teachings, right? And you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free. The truth will set you free. Not the truth will inform you. The truth will set you free. It's a very famous verse. So if you think about it, a truth that you invent for yourself can never actually set you free, can it? Because you can change it in a second. Especially if life starts to get a bit uncomfortable or your thinking gets uncomfortable about it. But a truth that exists outside you, that you didn't construct, that you didn't get to vote on— that's a truth that God seems to think can sustain you right now. Jesus is the one person in history who is precisely who he claims to be. No counterfeits, no emissions, no label hiding. Something underneath. And when we discover that truth, we are, Jesus says, set free. Free from our past, free from our shame, our fear, our old identity— everything in essence that seeks to kill, destroy, or steal. Kill or destroy us, according to John 10:10, which is critical, right? This isn't a truth that bullies you. This is a truth that sets you free. Now, if you remember, um, the property guy, the one who seemed trustworthy, whose silence kind of cost my family a lot. Well, it took me the best part of 15 years, but thanks to God's grace, we managed to pay back every penny. My mum's house, the one she fought for, is safe again. It is hers, free and clear, the way it should always have been. But I'll be honest with you, it doesn't tie up in a neat bow for me. I still have to carry the fact that she trusted me and it went wrong. But what I do keep coming back to is it went wrong because of a lack of truth. Pilate has Jesus in a room. He asked the right question. He was 3 feet from the answer to the only question that really matters. He asked the question. He just wouldn't stay in the room for the answer. Which really challenges me not to make the same mistake, right? The answer to the question, what is truth, was never a concept or an argument you win or lose. The answer has always been a person, and he's still in the room. He's not asking you to have it all figured out tonight. He's just asking you to stay long enough to listen. And if that stirred something in you— and sometimes the heart recognizes truth before the The mind has, you know, had all the chance it can to work it out. Then the simplest thing you can do tonight isn't to try and sort it all out. It's just simply not to walk away. You could pray something simple and honest like, Jesus, if you really are the truth, then I want to stay in the room. Help me not to walk out. Help me to understand it. What is truth? So here's my question for you. We're going to get into this conversation street. Hopefully you You picked up on this, guys, from the notes. Uh, and we're gonna ask the question, when was the last time you asked a big question about God, about life, about yourself, and then walked out of the room before you had chance to hear? So let's get into that. Back to you, beautiful people.

Sharon: Before— it's a great question. Before we get into that, I just want to say hello to a few people in the comments. So we've got Alicia, hi. Um, great to have you with us again. Um, a great name here, Starboy the Knight, who seems to speak fluent emoji. Welcome.

Matt: I'm still practicing my emoji.

Sharon: Yeah. Um, Vital, I'm not going to try and pronounce the rest of that. I'm going to get it very wrong, but welcome. And BB Dorian. And I can't see all the comments. I'm not sure if there's any—

Matt: Yeah, we've

Sharon: got

Matt: Nicola. Says it's my first time here.

Sharon: Fabulous.

Will: Welcome.

Matt: Yep. Always good to have you. Got Ellis, got Lady Birkby.

Sharon: Oh, there's you and me as well.

Matt: Are we in there?

Sharon: Hi. Yes.

Matt: Yeah. Hello.

Sharon: Hello to us.

Will: So that's some great stalling, Sharon, for the answer.

Sharon: Oh, you've, you've spotted what I'm doing.

Will: To Matt's completely flooring question.

Sharon: You're gonna have to repeat the question now because we've all forgotten with my interruption.

Matt: It's the idea, isn't it? Like, Pilate, I think, was in this room. He asked the question, what is truth? And he doesn't stay and wait for the answer.

Sharon: Yeah.

Will: Right.

Matt: And I'm intrigued, like, how many times I've done that in my own life. Like, probably just this week. Sure. I mean, where you're just like, God, what is going on? What is the truth here? And you don't really want to wait for the answer because you're probably not going to like the answer. Right? Um, or because you have an idea of what truth is or what truth should be, etc., etc. Um, and I was just kind of curious, is there any, any story that you have where you've kind of been your own version of pilot? And if you, if you guys watching have an answer to that question, I'd love to hear about it. Please write it in the comments. Uh, of course, if you're in Live Lounge, you can write it in the comments in Live Lounge as well. Um, we'd love to, to hear from you guys. Um, but yeah, that was the, the question.

Sharon: So, Will, what are your thoughts?

Will: I, I—

Matt: You need to get close to your microphone.

Will: To be honest, I can't, I can't think of, of anything particularly, but I was thinking a bit about Pilate and, um, I mean, gosh, if Pilate was distracted, how much more are we distracted? And I think it's, it's possibly a thing of distraction that you have these kind of moments of actually quite big questions, um, and then, yeah, 2 minutes later it's gone because there's something else that then vies for our attention. So I'm sure there's— I mean, it's kind of middle of the night sort of questions sometimes, and you're just like, oh, let's go back to sleep again. Or kind of waking questions which you then get— just get busy in your day and, and, and let it go again. And but I think God is very gracious, and when, when God is really trying to speak something to me, it'll come in several different packages through several different forms until I slowly begin to get the message. Um, but what's amazing actually is when you— if you do any kind of journaling, which I'm rubbish at, um, but sometimes reading back and going, oh yeah, I had some questions, I kind of wrote about them. Yeah. Oh, actually the answer came. I wasn't, I wasn't kind of in there in the room. Um, but yeah, the faithfulness of God To answer those questions. Um, yeah, it stuns, stuns me really. Um, I feel very blessed by that. But, um, no, I can't think of any, any particular situation.

Sharon: I think I relate to the being distracted because I think I do ask the questions and I do sort of listen, but I can get distracted from paying full attention. And that sort of came home to me today at lunchtime. So we, me and Matt, went to some friend's house for lunch, um, one of the founding couples of the church that we're part of. And, um, the guy— and we've been having a very frustrating time trying to find a new house. So we've moved out, we sold and moved out of our house back in August and are in a temporary place. And it's just been very frustrating trying to find somewhere new because we keep getting outbid. And I've been kind of going— I've, I've had a I think going through different stages, sometimes I'm just like, yeah, God, you know what, it's fine. I know that you've provided where we're living now, and I know you've got somewhere for us. And that is true.

Matt: At

Sharon: the same time, it's very frustrating. So Nick's question to me today was, what do you think is God saying in this? And it was like, oh, do you know what? I think I vaguely have got an idea of that, but I've not properly taken stock and gone, oh yeah, actually, I think this is what it is because I've just been distracted by lots of different things in life. So I think for me it is more of getting distracted, even though I am sort of half listening. I'm asking the questions, half listening. I'm then not taking that time to reflect and go, okay, what actually is this? And writing it down.

Matt: Yeah.

Sharon: And sometimes it is hard to tell, isn't it?

Will: Yeah, yeah, it is. And I, I think another thing that's— that probably prevents us is the world is not short of opinion. Um, I mean, it used to be, you know, when I was growing up, it would be maybe TV and a newspaper. Um, and that has exploded, um, to the point where trying to find— well, I mean, you could find every sort of opinion on any question you had, really. Mm-hmm. And, and very often that's where we start, rather than again shutting off all that noise and saying, God, what—

Matt: Yeah.

Will: What is it you're saying here? What, what's— what is truth here? Um, and it can be— yeah, I mean, there's a, there's a verse in James which says you're tossed to and fro by every wave and wind of the sea. It's, it's a, it's a very real experience, I think, for most of us, that we can be, uh, assaulted by different opinions and, and they then change our minds daily, um, about some things. Um, yeah.

Sharon: It's a great question to ask, isn't it? Especially in those situations where things don't naturally make sense. We just feel like we're getting nowhere. It's like, God, why? You know, God's not answered in the way that we want, in the timing that we want. And just to ask that, okay, God, you're not doing it the way that, you know, I'm expecting, I'm wanting. What are you saying? Um,

Matt: well, it's interesting because Alicia said here, I know sometimes I've asked the question, why me? Which doesn't always have to have a negative connotation, by the way, which is true. And then backed away from considering or praying for the answer. Right. So, and I think this is so true, isn't it? In terms of when things aren't quite going the way that you think that you want them to go. Right. Uh, we can ask the question, God, why? Um, but, and, and then actually not stay in and listen for the answer, or wrestle. Actually, it's not even a case of listening. Sometimes you have to wrestle, don't you, for the answer? Um, but I, going back to my, uh, original question in terms of, I think for me, the times I've been like pilot in the room, uh, is when I've had, um, as a Christian— you guys will have never done this, it's just me, uh— as a Christian is when you go, I have my theology, right? I'm right. And therefore I don't do

Will: that.

Matt: I don't never— I don't ever need to question what is true because I know what is true. Do

Sharon: you know

Matt: what I mean? And if I look back over my Christian walk, the, the theology I had 20 years ago is not the theology that I have now. Hmm. Right? That actually things have moved on and my understanding and my experience of life has changed. And I, I sometimes look back at what I was so dogmatic about early in my Christian walk that I was so convinced was true, and in some respects is true. Um, but in other respects, there's a lot more nuance and subtlety to it that the, the good Lord has seen fit to introduce to me.

Will: Do

Sharon: you know what I mean? Yeah, I can relate to that.

Matt: I do think as Christians we can get a bit, a little bit too dogmatic under this concept of truth. We know the truth, right? Because we know the gospel, um, and therefore we have our theology. And it's not that we should be, like you were saying, well, uh, tossed about and have weak theology. I think having good theology is a good thing to do. But I, I suppose the lesson I've learned over the years is not to be like Pilate and just assume I know what the answer is to the question, right? But actually to wrestle with it and to seek things out, um, and to spend some time understanding, um, what the good Lord is trying to get me to understand.

Sharon: Yeah.

Matt: Does that make sense?

Will: Yeah. Kath makes a very good point. in the chat about whether it was a rhetorical question, Pilate asking that. And I thought something similar, actually, that— I mean, Pilate is from an empire. You know, the Roman Empire was like, you know, it was the original spin. It was the original kind of pomp and hiding behind the kind of glitz. And I wonder even whether Pilate was so immersed in cynicism that he's kind of almost asking that question as like, what is truth?

Matt: Yeah.

Will: What are you talking about? about. Um, so whether it's rhetorical or cynical, but that, that can also be a real trap that we fall into. And I think that can really stop us hearing the truth of, of God sometimes, because we, we cut— we, we come so worn out with, with the lies and, and with the spin and, and, and the, the masks and everything else that actually we, when it comes to God even, we might apply that same cynicism to what we apply to—

Matt: Yeah.

Will: media, news, politicians, whatever, though, you know, there's the list of people that aren't trusted. Um, and, and that, yeah, that, that I find a challenge actually. And I have found a challenge in my life and continue to be challenged by that. And coming back to, um, that objective truth of God, and it is a real challenge. Jesus saying, I am the truth, the truth being a person. What, what exactly What exactly does that mean? It's not like I know the truth and I'm going to tell you. I thought, I thought that was really interesting what you said, Matt. Um, what does it mean to have a, a person who's the truth?

Sharon: Yeah, I've got so many thoughts now going off in different directions. So, um, you were talking about, you know, how when we hear so many lies, how do we know? And Matt made an interesting comment before, which was something like When you see enough counterfeits, you stop believing that there is such a thing as truth.

Will: Mm-hmm.

Sharon: And yeah, I think that if we have been lied to so many times, it can make it like, well, is there, is there any truth out there? But I think the thing with counterfeits is that they rely on there being the real thing. So that was just one thing that I wanted to point out from that. I had another I guess a question for you guys, for everybody. Um, where Jesus says, if you continue in my word, you'll know the truth and the truth will set you free. So these have been really important verses to me. I just wondered whether, you know, what your experience of experiencing that freedom through Jesus the truth— have you got some examples that you can give?

Will: Yeah, that's a good question. Um, I think for me, probably The, um, I don't quite know how to phrase it, the metrics of worth as the world would present them, um, is probably something as, as a young, young adult I would probably struggle with. So there was the kind of, you know, life is about achievement, it's about money, it's about whatever, um, all those, those kind of success and, and the, the drivenness of that and actually the, the pain in that because there's a constant doubt of like, have I got it to do that, what's expected of me? And, and that, that sort of wrestling of, am I going to be— am I living this life that everyone seems to think I should live? And, and that was a very, very profound freedom truth for me. God's acceptance and love of me just because. His grace just because. If I achieved nothing in my life, his love for me would not change. That was a very, very profound freedom truth for me.

Sharon: Yeah, me too. What about you?

Matt: Oh, so many ways, uh, and so many things. And I would say that probably, like Will, the key thing is identity. Right, where you have an opinion of yourself and you hold that up to— I love how the Bible talks about itself as a mirror— and you hold, hold your identity up to the mirror of God's word, and you see that what you believe about yourself and what God says about you, not always the same thing, really. Mm-hmm. And it's a bit like my analogy of, um, being in this room and not moving and moving at the same time. It's like There is the truth that I, I feel maybe shame, for example, but at the same time there's a reality of, um, he has set me free from shame, which is also true. And you hold this tension, like how I feel, how I perceive myself, how I understand myself. Um, and so yeah, I, I think for me a lot of it is tied into identity. Um, and just the change in me, I think, sometimes good, sometimes not so good. Do you know what I mean? I, I think before I was a Christian, I was quite shy. Um, I—

Sharon: It's hard to believe.

Matt: I know, I know. And it's like God's turned me into this maniac.

Will: God's got a lot to answer for.

Matt: Um, yeah, something like that. But I, I think it's like I can see where I was and I can see where God's brought me, um, from this insecure 18-year-old kid. You know, the whole world was revolving around me and, and just that big sense of identity. Um, even things like before we got married. So, um, my— like I said earlier, my parents got divorced when, uh, when I was about 9 years old in the early '80s. You're starting to do the maths, aren't you? How old is Matt? Um,

Sharon: he's 53, so if you work it out—

Matt: Thanks, babe. Wow. Um, and so, yeah, so I grew up in an environment where, uh, my— both my parents would, you know, they, they were obviously divorced. And so what did relationships look like? And so I knew that in my early 20s, before I started dating, the thing that I had to do was spend some time in the Bible and understand what it meant to be a husband, right? Because the only good marriages I'd seen were when I joined church when I was 18. Um, apart from one or two, but the, the, the, the sort of the general rule was the marriages are useless. Um, and I needed God's truth to change how I thought about being a husband. Um, and here we are 28 years later. I don't always get it right, but I'm a really good husband now.

Sharon: He actually is. He's not just saying that.

Matt: No, I am just saying that, honestly.

Will: I think we've talked about it quite a lot in Crowd before, but the the, the difficulty of my truth, your truth that we live in, um, with that identity thing that we've all kind of experienced, of the pressure of like, oh, it's all, it's all subjective, it's all about my truth that I have to either create and broadcast in this world of social media, or, or at least have some, some sort of coherence, is a huge, huge pressure. And if we felt it Back in the '80s, you know, even more so. I see my kids now and go, there is a massive pressure to, to sort of invent your truth almost, or, or to kind of, yeah, to, to, to build that. And if you've not got that kind of security of there being any objective truth foundation that you're settling on apart from gravity, um, that's incredibly stressful. And that can actually be— It's cause a lot of anxiety. And I know that as an adult, um, let alone as someone building my identity as a young adult.

Sharon: Yeah, really good point. Um, are there any comments that we could pick up on that I can't actually see?

Matt: Uh, sure, let's go through them. So, um, Dion says, I think we humans can be quite impatient when waiting for truth to be realized, a byproduct of a society that doesn't value waiting or patience. This is so true. Um, and I think there is a— there is— I mean, we didn't get a chance to get into it, did it? But it's one of those things where there is this biblical idea of discovering truth almost being like a wrestling match. And we saw this early on— was it Jacob wrestling with God, wasn't it? And he broke his leg, sort of thing. And it's that whole idea that actually we live in a culture which goes, right, what's truth? And I expect just want to write it out on a piece of paper, or maybe AI is going to tell me now. Um, but there— I think often in our Christian walks there is an element of we have to wrestle this out, we have to search it out and find it out.

Will: No, absolutely.

Matt: And this is what Dion is saying, and I think it's so true, Dion. Yeah, I think it's a great comment.

Will: And if you, if you kind of— I'm no philosopher, but if you look at the sort of philosophy of truth, there's, there's, there's a couple of ways you could think about it. And one is a kind I think it's called correspondence or coherence theory, whereby actually there's— you don't take one thing, you don't read one verse and go— there's actually lots of different things that begin to make a coherence, and you have to wrestle and you have to search that and you have to actually go on the journey a little bit. So if we're talking about with God, um, don't settle for, you know, a preach or, or a verse on a poster or something like that. There's a there's a, well, check this out. And the more I've done that through my life as a Christian in the Bible and through meeting other Christians, there's nothing that, that undercuts it. You know, when you start doing that, maybe it may be a story, a news story, and you start looking at other sources and you start hearing other opinions and you go, oh, actually, yeah, it's not quite what I thought. There's a bit of, you know, that's overinflated. With God, that has absolutely not been the case. And, and, and that's I think a challenge to us all not to be in a hurry, as Matt said, to kind of like, oh, I should be able to write it on a Post-it note, that's the truth. There are very key scriptures and truths about Christ that we've talked about in this series that sum it up, but actually in terms of our own walk with God, it's really important to be kind of getting those multiple checks of like, well, if God says this, what about this? Yeah. go and explore that. Um, and your experience is part of that as well. Um, yeah.

Sharon: Yeah. I'm aware of time. Yes. I think we, yes, we need to be wrapping up. Well, uh, stopping the conversation on the livestream, but we're gonna carry it on in live lounge.

Matt: Before you do that.

Sharon: Yes.

Matt: Um,

Sharon: well,

Matt: let me just say, no, no, no, not at all. There are a lot of comments here we've not had a chance to get to, and we're not ignoring them genuinely. It's a, it's a time issue. Thank you to everyone who has commented. Um, uh, I saw a comment, uh, from Nicola. How do I get to Live Lounge? Hopefully you've seen— oh, there's one coming up as I speak. There's a little ticker on the bottom. Um, on there you'll see Live Lounge, uh, with a URL. Um, you just type that in, go.crowd.church/livelounge. That'll bring you— yeah, here it is on the screen. Just perfect timing. Thank you, Lord. Um, if you type that into a web browser, it will open up the right Zoom room. So just follow that and you will be able to join us, Nicola. And also, I just wanted to give a quick shout out to Gordon who said hi. So,

Sharon: uh,

Matt: yes.

Sharon: I have so many questions. One I wanted to ask you guys, which we can maybe do in Live Lounge, is has anyone come up against part of this truth of Jesus that actually has been quite difficult to— like, it's a truth that you're like, oh, actually that's quite Hard. One I don't really like. I would prefer it if—

Will: Plenty.

Sharon: Oh, it sounds like, okay, there's quite a lot there. Um, yeah, so that, I mean, that's a question I would definitely love to ask. So we will continue this conversation in Live Lounge, but do come back and join us next week. Or we also have midweek groups on a Wednesday, 7:30 UK time, which again, if you go to the website, uh, you should be able to find out more information there. So, uh, I'm gonna say goodbye now. Thank you very much for joining us. Hope to see you in Live Lounge. In a minute.

Matt: Fantastic.

More talks